• Home
  • Our Team
  • Useful links
  • Blog
  • Contact
P2G LLP

What is still wrong with PF2?

15/1/2015

0 Comments

 
In 2012 the Treasury issued “A new approach to public private partnerships”, otherwise known as PF2. Whilst an improvement on the original PFI, we believe that PF2 has failed to address some important issues. Here we look at four problem areas that remain in PF2, which continually arise in our work with the Public Sector helping to manage their existing PFI contracts:

1 Use of Advisors
Whilst section 2.2 of the PF2 guidance points to the early appointment of advisors; there is no guidance on the scope of appointments for advisors for the Public Sector. Time and time again we see errors in the operational contracts that are primarily due to the lack of coordination between the legal,  technical, financial and insurance advisors’ scope of service. The reality is that a commercial lead should be appointed to oversee the work carried out by these different disciplines to ensure that the awarded contract is fit for purpose.

2 The ability to change the contract
Whilst section 11.2.12 recognises the potential need to change the contract for issues other than Works or Services, unless the standard form explicitly enshrines this right, which it does not, it will remain the subject of continued disputes with the private sector. 

3 Persistent Breach
The current guidance (23.2.3) is that minor breaches should be dealt with via performance points, with persistent breach termination rights only being enshrined in the contract if the performance points do not adequately incentivise the private sector to rectify minor breaches. Experience to date has shown that remedies using performance points are treated by the private sector on a purely business case basis. If the performance points are worth a deduction of £1 but the cost of rectification is £10, they will rarely bother to rectify the breaches. As such we believe that it should be mandatory for persistent breach termination rights to be enshrined in the PF2 contract.

4 Due diligence over subcontracts
Section 27 does make a small number of recommendations over the level of due diligence that an Authority should carry out on the subcontracts. In reality this is where any Authority should ensure that a high level of due diligence is carried out. The Authority needs an in depth understanding of a whole range of issues: the way the subcontractors have priced delivery, levels of margins, loss of profit rights for early termination, responsibilities for latent defects, and risk allocation. The list of issues that can fundamentally affect an Authority over the lifetime of the contract is vast and PF2 guidance does not go nearly far enough. 
0 Comments

Sell-off

13/1/2015

0 Comments

 
Peter Bach's independent film, Sell-off, highlights the pressures the NHS is under. Naturally PFI is heavily featured. You can watch the whole thing, below, or visit the Sell-off website.
0 Comments

P2G charitable donation for 2014

12/1/2015

0 Comments

 
Each year, P2G donate 10% of profits to charity. This is our second year of operations. In our first year we chose the children's medical research charity, Sparks. This year, despite Bruce having his own bike stolen and Russell managing to walk past ranks of Boris bikes every day without even being tempted, our charitable donations were cycling themed. 

Cycling has obvious health and environmental benefits. A team of trust staff and private sector partners at University College Hospital London showed that it can also raise money for a good cause. P2G donated £2,000 in sponsoring their “Mallorca 300” cycling fundraiser, which raised a total of £50,000 for Great Ormond Street Hospital
.

Picture
UCLH-Partners participating in the "Mallorca 300" for GOSH photo: oliver_neilson
Unfortunately, cycling also has its dangers. Every year in the UK 19,000 cyclists are involved in accidents, 3,000 of which result in death or serious injury. Despite these numbers, the data available is poor and policy decisions are often made on the basis of speculation rather than clear evidence. The Royal London Hospital has seen a 400% rise in the number of cyclists killed or injured in recent years.
Picture
Serious cycling casualties requiring full trauma team activities at RLH
In response, Barts Charity ran a unique, multi-disciplinary seminar chaired by Jon Snow, with the subsequent launch of its Safe Cycling Appeal. Their flagship project being to compile a database on cycling injuries to address the poor state of information currently available. This new data will be used to monitor and reduce such incidents in the future. Our £14,792 donation has helped the campaign to reach a significant project milestone but much more can be done. Please take a look at the campaign website and donate if you can.
Picture
The Royal London Hospital
We're looking for good causes for next year's donation. If you have any suggestions, please let us know by email.
0 Comments

    Authors

    The authors have experience of more than 100 PFI projects in multiple sectors.

    Archives

    March 2022
    January 2022
    September 2021
    March 2021
    April 2020
    March 2020
    October 2019
    September 2019
    June 2019
    March 2019
    May 2018
    June 2017
    October 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    October 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    Categories

    All
    Charitable Donation
    Code Of Conduct
    Contracts
    Covid 19
    Covid-19
    Damage
    Honesty
    Insurance
    Monthly Reports
    News
    PF2
    Pfi
    PFI Handback
    PPM
    Profit
    Public Sector
    Relationships
    Savings
    Secondary Market
    Special Purpose Companies
    Vacancy

    RSS Feed

P2G LLP
A Social Enterprise Partnership
Registered in England & Wales
No. OC375527
​P2G Contract Support LLP
Registered in England & Wales
No. OC419519